Weekly

T5W: Books featuring Mental Health

Top 5 Wednesday is a goodreads group created by Lainey (gingerreadslainey) and now hosted by Sam (thoughtsontomes). This week’s topic is Books featuring Mental Health.

What I look for in mental illness representation and books that talk about mental health, across genres, is mostly something that makes sense emotionally. Which is why I’m including novels that talk about mental illness/mental health that use the paranormal or sci-fantasy technology to make their point. If anything, those kinds of stories resonate with me more than a lot of “accurate” representation – many novels that try to be realistic while also having the main character still be likable (as most contemporaries do) feel toned down to me. If we have to get into paranormal or sci-fantasy territory to explain how terrifying it can get for the person experiencing it, how it sometimes seems to warp reality, then why not.


This Is What It Feels Like by Rebecca Barrow

36039320

This is one of the most underrated contemporary novels I’ve ever read, and if you trust what I say about contemporaries (which isn’t much, I know, this is mostly an SFF blog), please read this?

It’s a story about three girls who were once friends as they reconnect through music, and it talks about recovery in all its three PoVs:

  • Hannah is recovering from alcoholism;
  • Jules was in a toxic relationship and mentally is still dealing with the aftermath of that;
  • The boy Dia loved died unexpectedly, and this book talks about how grief can lead to magical thinking (as in, if I get close to someone else they’ll die too)

These are all heavy themes, but the way this book is written, the way it focuses on recovery more than anything, makes it… if not exactly a light read, certainly not a sad or difficult one either.


The Dark Beneath the Ice by Amelinda Bérubé

32941909

This novel’s representation of anxiety was so good that it made realize things about my own. It’s a story about the consequences of avoidance as a coping mechanism, and if you’re thinking, but it looks like a paranormal horror novel – it is. It uses a horror metaphor to explain what happens when one does that, and it’s not pretty, and I love that this book doesn’t try to to hide it.

It’s the only novel I’ve read so far in which not only the main character starts taking medication (antipsychotics, outside of a contemporary issue novel? yes), but also talks about having side effects while still presenting it in a mostly positive way.


For a Muse of Fire by Heidi Heilig

36220335

For a Muse of Fire would be a pretty typical rebel-against-evil-people-in-power YA fantasy, but it would be wrong to describe anything with a queer Southeast Asian heroine with bipolar disorder as “typical”, wouldn’t it? And anyway, of all the novels with this kind of plot I’ve read, this is one of the best.

Heidi Heilig said that she chose to write this novel “the way being bipolar feels like“, and the way this is done both through the pacing and the mixed media format is amazing. Also, I always like to read about mentally ill people in YA who are heroes even though they have very little support system in their own world, because I didn’t have one when I was the main characters’ age either.


Final Draft by Riley Redgate

35960813

I don’t know if there is (and which is) an English equivalent of this, but Italian literature classes spend a lot of time on Giacomo Leopardi. There’s very little I hated as much as the time we spent on Giacomo Leopardi, because it meant having to spend a lot of time listening to teachers say very insensitive things about suicide and talk about how suffering makes your art so much better. It’s not the poet’s fault, and it’s not the only time the “tormented artist” myth was presented as pure truth, but still, so many bad memories.

Reading a novel like Final Draft, a novel dedicated specifically to shatter that stereotype, a novel whose entire message is that the pursuit of art isn’t worth your mental health, was very refreshing.


Machineries of Empire by Yoon Ha Lee

One thing that somewhat annoys me about fantasy and science fiction as it is today is how a lot of it makes characters go through unimaginably horrible things without addressing the mental toll these kinds of things would have on a person.

And if it does, it usually does so in a very specific way – the main character is ok at the beginning, goes through bad things and is in a bad mental place, but once the obstacles are gone, recovery is… if not instant, at least quick and certain.

I was surprised when I realized that the Machineries of Empire series wasn’t that kind of story. Most characters these novels follow are dealing with mental illnesses and the consequences of trauma (and in some cases of abuse) – and they usually are already at the beginning of the novel, and more often than not still are by the end of it. A mentally ill character’s arc doesn’t have to be “gets ill then gets cured”; there’s so much more about a person that their illness or trauma.

(Also, most of them aren’t good people, and it might sound odd, but I actually really appreciate that.)


Other Books

These are novels I didn’t like as much as a whole, but in which I appreciated how some mental health-related topics were portrayed/discussed, so I want to talk about them.

  • Paris Adrift by E.J. Swift: this was the first time I ever saw panic attacks represented in a fantasy book, and this novel will always hold a special place in my heart because of that. Also, the more you read it the more it feels like a fever dream, which is exactly what I mean when I say that I look for “what makes sense emotionally” in books featuring topics related to mental health. A warped perception of reality, and it makes you feel that!
  • The Price Guide to the Occult by Leslye Walton: plot-wise, this book was a mess. However, the simple fact that it featured a main character who had to drop out of high school because of depression but is now recovering and isn’t shamed for any of this made me like it far more than Walton’s previous book. I did go very close to having to repeat a year in high school because of anxiety [I don’t know how it is in other countries but in Italy there’s a mandatory oral exam at the end of high school and if you don’t pass it it’s likely that you’ll have to repeat the last year], so it means a lot to me to see this.
  • Under Rose-Tainted Skies by Louise Gornall: this is an m/f romance/issue book, which is really not my thing, but I have to say that the mental illness representation in it – agoraphobia and OCD – was amazing. We rarely see main characters who are so deeply affected, we almost only see ones that manage to go to school and have friends, and… that’s not everyone’s experience and I’m glad this book exists.

What are your favorite books that talk about mental health?

15 thoughts on “T5W: Books featuring Mental Health

  1. I’ve finally bought a copy of This Is What It Feels Like and I’m so excited to read both that one and Final Draft! The fact that you read mostly SFF weirdly makes me trust you even more when it comes to contemporary, I guess I figure you’re as picky as me about them. Wonderful post!

    Liked by 1 person

      1. I don’t want to spoil too much- but the MC has anxiety. There is a decent focus on how she overcomes it, but also how medicating for it has a negative connotation with others. It’s a great read!

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I knew Dark Beneath the Ice and Machineries would be on the list! ❤

    I 10000% agree with you on speculative books with mental health being more resonant than contemporary. I mean, there are definitely times when it felt like my episodes weren't real. Like they were some fantastical, otherworldly experiences (but not in a good way). And sometimes it takes SFF/horror to get that across.

    And oh my god, I would have flipped my lid in those lit classes. It angers me when I see people in positions of influence and power talking about how suffering leads to better art. But for teachers to say that to their students is just so so *especially* irresponsible.

    I know it's on your TBR, but you should really try Borderline! It's fun and not super dense, and I love how BPD is so carefully explained.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Well I am predictable

      The amount of ignorant things teachers can get away with saying, at least here, is… terrifying, and I tried doing something about that only once (didn’t go well). Between this and the shameless homophobia, I mostly tried not to listen. Italy is a treasure and I’m so glad I’m not in high school anymore.

      And yes, Borderline is on my TBR and I hope to get to it this year!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I love that The Dark Beneath The Ice is on here! ❤ a book I enjoyed a couple years back that I never see anyone talk about is Terminal Regression by Mallory Hill, which is a dystopian book, but really it's all about a protagonist who is depressed and struggling with suicidal ideation. like, she nominates herself for euthanasia which is what happens to people in that society who don't contribute because she can't deal with being alive anymore. annnd obviously it doesn't go to plan otherwise there wouldn't be a book, lol

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s